Advertisement

The Dear Hunter - Act 1: The Lake South the River North

Rating

single starsingle starsingle starsingle starhalf star

RIYL

Silverchair
The Mars Volta
Jeff Buckley
DeVotchKa
Codeseven

Tracklist

1. Battesimo Del Fuoco
2. The Lake South
3. City Escape
4. The Inquiry Of Ms. Terri
5. 1878
6. The Pimp And The Priest
7. His Hands Matched His Tongue
8. The River North

Users Rating

single starsingle starsingle starsingle star
4 ratings

Your Rating

Create an account or log in to rate this album

Recent Ratings

You've never heard a debut quite like The Dear Hunter's Act 1: The Lake South, The River North. Sure, it's almost impossible that you haven't heard the sounds found on this record before, but the catch is, you've never heard them put together quite like this.

It's almost impossible not to think of critical darlings and over-self-indulgers The Mars Volta for nearly the entire length of "City Escape," which has everything The Mars Volta has, right down to the brief quiet electronic near-noise interlude, but minus the penchant for going off the deep end and delving into the vast recesses of vacuous boredom. The vocals also don't grate on the listener as much. In fact, the song maintains the listener's attention for its entire length, making it miles better than the past two The Mars Volta releases. Take notes, because this is how you write an interesting six-minute track.

Of course, it is almost necessary to jump right to the third track when reviewing this disc, as the first two tracks act simply as introductions. It is difficult to recall an album using two intro tracks, but they're nicely done here. "Battisimo del Fuoco" can appear to be either a fine display of the subtlety of vocal phrasing or a complete waste of time, because no one cares that "the flame is gone, the fire remains." That doesn't really matter, though, because "The Lake South" is heavily in the DeVotchKa/Beirut vein and I, for one, couldn't be happier, as DeVotchKa has quickly climbed the ladder in my list of favorite bands.

However, after "City Escape," The Dear Hunter truly begins to take on a sound entirely its own, fusing more The Mars Volta love with hefty doses of Codeseven, Cursive, and Silverchair thrown into the mix. It's a very disparate group of influences that mastermind Casey Crescenzo brings together to near-perfection. The album is fragile, yet powerful, as Crescenzo not only sings his heart out, but also writes some of the most interesting music of the year. There honestly is not much wrong with The Lake South, The River North, aside from the typo on the side of the case.

It's becoming increasingly rare to hear an album that makes you crave the band's next release. Rarer still is the album that makes you check on their history to find bands in which the members have previously partaken. I've never heard The Receiving End of Sirens, but they might just get thrown into my list of "bands to check out," even if I never listen to anything they do post-2005. But the rarity of The Dear Hunter doesn't stop there. No, sir. The Dear Hunter makes me positively giddy to hear past, present, and new releases from Beirut, Ben Folds, Brazzaville, Jeff Buckley, Call Me Ishmael, Codeseven, Coheed and Cambria, Decibully, DeVotchKa, Dredg, Incubus, The Mars Volta, Paulson, Silverchair, Skeleton Key, and even, at times during "The Pimp and the Priest," Panic! At the Disco, and untold numbers of other bands simply by picking up on the very essence of what made these bands so appealing and putting them all together into one tiny little EP packed with more zeal and pleasantry than the newest of politicians. Never have I heard an album that brought out as much passion to hear and seek out music by artists I at one time adored but for, one reason or another, don't listen to nearly enough anymore, quite like The Dear Hunter has done here. Enough cannot be said.

An absolute delight, The Lake South, The River North is genuine, ingenious, well-crafted, marvelous, masterful, and much, much more. This is one of those albums where you will hear something new with every listen, no matter how often you listen to it. We all know those make for the best albums anyway. Casey Crescenzo has firmly established himself as a one-man musical wrecking crew whose vision is too pure for a world so worn with bland, run-of-the-mill, same-old-same-old, day-after-day drudgery in every aspect of our waking lives.

--Ben Rice

Author

sir mix-a-lot
Last updated: 09/29/2009 08:54PM

Comments

HEARTandSYNAPSE
10/26/2006
06:50AM
Location
Manchester, England
great review ben. This really didn;t grab me at first, and i LOVELOVELOVE TREOS and the Dear Hunter demo-album. so i think i owe it to myself to try again with this.
awake_and_avenge
10/26/2006
09:56AM
Age: 27
Location
Tucson, AZ
Good review, Ben, this is an incredible ALBUM.
Roncag
10/26/2006
10:08AM
Age: 30
Location
Anytown USA
Yea I think it's pretty fantastic. I hope a full length follows shortly.

You play to win the game.

Jeremy Deal
10/26/2006
10:32AM
Age: 30
Just listened to this again this morning - solid, solid release.

"These are our lives, but did they ever even matter - are we worth remembering?"
- "Tip The Scales"
Rise Against

Dan Alcinii
10/26/2006
11:23AM
Age: 23
Location
Toronto, Ontario
Try as I might, this album won't catch my ear.

"Use short sentences. Use short first paragraphs. Use vigorous English. Be positive, not negative."

MySpace / Facebook

daganjatribe
10/26/2006
04:19PM
Location
Austin
this cd owns, good review

The Daily Galaxy
An elephant that never forgets...to kill!

GhostHero76
10/26/2006
04:31PM
Location
AZ
this is a really good album, thanks for the tip. I've been listening to the whole thing on purevolume all day
a night eclipsed
10/26/2006
08:58PM
Location
nj
this album is close to the album of the year for me. such an amazing piece of work. the receiving end of sirens is such an amazing band as well and i was really bummed out when Casey said he was leaving them. But if both bands TREOS and TDH can keep putting out releases in vein of their last masterpieces then it was worth it.

Josh Hofer
10/27/2006
09:41AM
Age: 26
Location
Raleigh, NC
amazing record.
Jacko
10/27/2006
10:23AM
Location
Wiltshire, UK
I bloody love this record, beautiful stuff.
sovietnoodle
10/27/2006
11:32AM
Location
Colorado
def. a good cd....i heard P!atd similarities the most....but this is years beyond Panic. Good cd.
AndyY9587
10/27/2006
11:35AM
Age: 23
Location
Cincinnati, OH
This kinda bores me
Zach Roth
10/29/2006
09:51AM
Age: 22
Location
Nazareth, Pennsylvania
Dare I say, that this is what The Sound of Animals Fighting should have sounded like? They were trying to be eperimental, expressive, and eclectic.

This album packs orchestral instrumentals, low-fi noise portions, an impressive array of unconventional instruments and song structures for a rock record, a number of different vocal styles from quiet and reserved to loud and aggressive, and a good array of other qualities.

They tried so hard to situate themselves far away from the norm that they made an album that not only alienated potential fans, but also existing fans. Meanwhile, Mr. Credenzo has managed to write and execute this masterpiece using a lot of the elements I would say these two bands have in common.

Just throwing that out there.


"(Hoo-oo-oo-oo-oo-oo!) Alright alright alright! (Hoo-oo-oo-oo-oo-oo!) Ah, ah, ah, ah! (Hoo-oo-oo-oo-oo-oo!) Alright alright alright! (Hoo-oo-oo-oo-oo-oo!) Ah, ah, ah, ah!"

iamnotyourbroom
10/29/2006
11:31AM
Location
Charleston, SC
this is one of the best albums i have ever heard....gorgeous
xtakesthesquare
11/30/2006
11:45PM
Location
New Jersey
More people need to hear this. I only just listened and I'm already hooked.

when i see it in your eyes
i just want to go blind

DecoyOctopus
12/02/2006
10:16PM
Haha, it sure is cool to hate The Mars Volta now.

Anyway, I liked this a ton.