And Then There Were None - Who Speaks for Planet Earth

Rating

single starhalf star

RIYL

Playradioplay!
Hellogoodbye
Boys Like Girls
Aqua

Release Date

02/24/2009

Tracklist

1. Intro
2. Arsonist
3. The Hospital
4. Reinventing Robert Cohn
5. Action
6. The Atmosphere
7. Cloak and Dagger
8. Right Here Waiting
9. Bed of Nails
10. Watchmaker
11. The Alamo
12. Insozzz

Users Rating

single star
3 ratings

Your Rating

Create an account or log in to rate this album

Recent Ratings

tim
single starhalf star

Many artists have mellowed out during their careers, often switching from metalcore to more of a rock sound. Cave In did it with Jupiter, This Day Forward did it with In Response, and Glassjaw did it with Worship and Tribute. Now, one of the newest bands to make the transition is New Hampshire’s own And Then There Were None.

With a strong work ethic and constant DIY tours, And Then There Were None built up a strong following playing metalcore akin to As I Lay Dying and Darkest Hour. After their last release with a small indie label, And Then There Were None completely revamped their sound to techno inspired indie rock and signed to Tooth and Nail Records. While the band’s tenacity has rightfully earned them a spot on a premier label, their new full length fails to deliver on many levels, making Who Speaks for Planet Earth a huge disappointment.

The main issue with this release is the lack of diversity and the one-dimensional songwriting. It’s hard to fathom why a band would have the same drum beat in every single chorus on their album, especially when they are a drum and bass focused band. After a few songs, listeners will most likely end up with a headache from the quarter note bass drum pounding throughout Who Speaks for Planet Earth. Granted, this is techno inspired music so it’s meant to be upbeat, but surely there are other beats to play besides the one used here. Additionally, the vocals are adequate but nothing special and go off key a few times, most notably on the choruses of “Reinventing Robert Cohen” and “The Alamo.” Moreover, the vocal melodies aren’t very memorable, leaving little reason to listen to the songs again.

Despite the lackluster music and vocals, the arrangements in the songs are well written. And Then There Were None uses different instrumentation and synth sounds on the verses to mix things up; it’s the choruses that are the problem. Also, there are a couple of parts with acoustic drums that sound pretty solid, it’s a shame the band doesn’t explore that side more because those are the better parts of the album. Additionally, being a Richard Marx fan, the “Right Here Waiting” cover is the highlight of the album. It’s unfortunate that a cheesy song from the 1980’s is the best part, but the track is enjoyable nonetheless.

And Then There Were None is a really hard working band and paid their dues to get to where they are now; there’s no arguing that. However, Who Speaks for Planet Earth has too many issues to ignore and can literally be painful to listen to at times. Hopefully they’ll either figure out a better way of playing this style of music or switch genres again; either way, the band needs to go back to the drawing board.

--Nicholas Fritz

Last updated: 09/29/2009 09:04PM

Comments

Bill Lohr
02/18/2009
07:48AM
Age: 30
Location
Lehigh Valley, PA

Yea...they were awesome years back when they were a metalcore band. Myself and other members of the Decoy family have played with them a bunch, and they are the nicest dudes so I wish them the best of luck. But I agree, this album and the revamping of the band is just not good.

Rick Gebhardt
02/18/2009
07:50AM
Age: 33
Location
Minnesota

When I first listened to this I thought that T&N sent me the wrong disc to review by accident.  I actually searched around online for a while before I believed they turned from an ok metalcore band to an absolutely atrocious electro-pop band.  The worst part about this album is that it is simply BORING. 

Find me EVERYWHERE:




NapalmTheChildren
02/18/2009
08:22AM
Location
Jersey / Raleigh

" Cave In did it with Jupiter, This Day Forward did it with In Response, and Glassjaw did it with Worship and Tribute. Now, one of the newest bands to make the transition is New Hampshire’s own And Then There Were None. "

how dare you....

Rick Gebhardt
02/18/2009
09:03AM
Age: 33
Location
Minnesota
NapalmTheChildren

" Cave In did it with Jupiter, This Day Forward did it with In Response, and Glassjaw did it with Worship and Tribute. Now, one of the newest bands to make the transition is New Hampshire’s own And Then There Were None. "

how dare you....

Yeah, And Then There Were None should not be mentioned in the same sentence as those bands, let alone the same review!

Find me EVERYWHERE:




Mike Duchnowsky
02/18/2009
09:14AM
Age: 30
Location
West Haven, CT
NapalmTheChildren

" Cave In did it with Jupiter, This Day Forward did it with In Response, and Glassjaw did it with Worship and Tribute. Now, one of the newest bands to make the transition is New Hampshire’s own And Then There Were None. "

how dare you....

I don't know about glassJAW they always sort of seem to change and they were never "metalcore".
Cave In did it big time with Jupiter. And Then There Were None were never really all that great.

Fuckings Greatest Hits: 2013 |2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 | 2008

I'll take no gold miss,
I'll take no silver
I'll take those sweet lips,
And I'll deliver.

Nicholas Fritz
02/18/2009
09:26AM
Age: 31
Location
Quakertown, PA
NapalmTheChildren

" Cave In did it with Jupiter, This Day Forward did it with In Response, and Glassjaw did it with Worship and Tribute. Now, one of the newest bands to make the transition is New Hampshire’s own And Then There Were None. "

how dare you....

Yeah, I see your point.

I was just trying to illustrate the drastic change in sound, and those were the best examples I could think of the time. The most relevant being Jupiter because that was a huge leap, This Day Forward gradually became mellower, and Glassjaw became a bit more commercial. And yeah, Glassjaw isn't technically a metalcore band but like I said, I was trying to make people realize the huge shift in sound using well know albums.

tim
02/21/2009
05:07AM
Age: 31
Location
Green Brook, NJ

haha. riyl: aqua.