Agalloch - Ashes Against the Grain

Rating

single starsingle starsingle starsingle starhalf star

RIYL

Empyrium
Opeth
Mono
Explosions In The Sky

Tracklist

1. Limbs
2. Falling Snow
3. This White Mountain on Which You Will Die
4. Fire Above, Ice Below
5. Not Unlike the Waves
6. Our Fortress is Burning... I
7. Our Fortress is Burning... II - Bloodbirds
8. Our Fortress is Burning... III - The Grain

Users Rating

single starsingle starsingle starsingle starhalf star
3 ratings

Your Rating

Create an account or log in to rate this album

Recent Ratings

Max
single starsingle starsingle starsingle starhalf star

For the last decade Agalloch have been pushing the boundaries of metal, creating a sound that is truly their own by exploring territory both dark and warm from not only a musical standpoint, but vocally and lyrically as well. In 1999 they released their first full length, the astonishing Pale Folklore. A near masterpiece in itself, it was only to be eclipsed by their following output of The Mantle three years later, considered by myself and many to be a landmark in folk, doom, or whatever other subgenre of metal one could use to describe its sound. Now, after four long years, the band has returned with a slightly different approach, but one that holds up easily to their previous offerings in every imaginable way.

Beginning with possibly the best song they've ever written, the band introduce us to the warm and beautiful sounds of "Limbs". After a distant echo is left to ring and enter our concious for a short period of time, it's eclipsed by a cascading barrage of epic and powerful electronic guitars, creating an incredibly pleasant melody that continues for nearly half of the song. As the passage begins to fade, it gives way to the band's oh-so-familiar acoustics for a brief period of time, and finally introduces what will be the central melody of gorgeous tremolo riffing. More than five minutes into the track, John Haughm greets us with his unique vocal rasps. Sounding neither forced or fierce, his harsh vocals approach a sound of wonder and awe, showing a great passion for the message he's conveying to the listener. Before approaching the song's nearly indescribable climax, the melodies and vocals take a back seat to a soft and lonely acoustic arrangement. Finally, the band conclude the song with what must be their most beautiful of arrangements as a post rock inspired build-up leads itself into a somber and appropriate tremolo picked melody over John's mournful rasps. One of the most powerful endings to any song in recent memory, the final lyrics lend themselves perfectly to the imagery created by the music: "...Earth to flesh, flesh to wood, cast these limbs into the water. Flesh to wood, wood to stone, cast this stone into the water..."

Though "Limbs" is, for me, the highlight of the record, that's not to say the following tracks aren't drenched in remarkable qualities as well. The following track "Falling Snow" introduces a light and uplifting guitar lead before morphing into a moderate pace for the rest of it's near-ten minute running time. This track, and it seems the entirety of the album, is a lyrical continuation of "Limbs", in what seems to be at least a loose-concept based around the death of man, becoming one with the Earth, and the failure of humanity as a whole. Also introduced for the first time on the album are John's unique clean vocals which always manage to evoke an incredible sense of longing.

After a brief but ominous ambient piece, "Fire Above, Ice Below" gives us the most prominent example of Agalloch's imminent post rock influence within their music. Throughout the track are epic and drawn out melodies of various kinds, including a quiet composition that wouldn't have been out of place on "The Mantle". The climactic ending of the song approaches the greatness of that found on "Limbs", as an outpouring of overlapping guitar riffs drain the life from one another until the only remaining sound is of a strong and steady wind; of which briefly overlaps into "Not Unlike the Waves", yet another unique track in Agalloch's catalogue. Featuring a rare groove section that calls Opeth to mind and some agonizing Burzum-esque rasps from John, the song seems a bit more complex and involving than the others found on this record. As such, and with good reason, it may stand out to some listeners.

The album winds itself down in a trilogy of sorts with "Our Fortress Is Burning", though only the first two sections are assembled as one. Part one sets the tone for the longer, more elaborate "Bloodbirds" found in the second section. Both of these tracks are reminiscent of the material found on The Mantle, while at the same time seem to expand on the post rock tendencies scattered throughout this record. Though at first I was disappointed with the final section of this three part conclusion, I've come to embrace it with repeated listens. As a seven minute ambient piece, it is both haunting and effective, though I can't help thinking that more could have been done with the finale of this incredible album.

With Ashes Against the Grain, these men have not only become my favorite metal band, but one of my favorite artists of all time. Unlike any group before or after them, Agalloch continue to create their own form of art within music and poetry, allowing it to seem curiously familiar deep inside one's soul, yet utterly foreign on the most basic levels of explaination and understanding. Along with maybe two or three other bands, the aural arrangements created by this particular group of individuals is as close as music comes to being purely transcendent.

--Matthew Dyess

Last updated: 09/29/2009 08:54PM

Comments

Inevitable
10/04/2006
07:58AM
Location
Sheffield
Indeed...Without doubt one of the strongest records of the year..In my top ten definitely..That's quite an achievement seeing as there's only another two, maybe three I'd have in there at the moment..
Tempus
10/04/2006
10:26AM
Location
Canada
They've never been anything more than average to me; this CD is no exception.
Fractal_Mortality
10/04/2006
10:40AM
Insanely good album. It just edges out the Mantle, in my opinion, which was already a masterpiece in my eyes.

Sins Of Arcadia
10/04/2006
10:50AM
Age: 28
Location
Florida, USA
Tempus fails at music.

I wrote this review, so you already know my stance.

Amazing record, amazing band. Period.
Tempus
10/04/2006
01:05PM
Location
Canada
Sins Of Arcadia
Tempus fails at music.



*looks at your last.fm*

Ahaha, cute.
awake_and_avenge
10/04/2006
01:18PM
Age: 29
Location
Tucson, AZ
Good album, dull review.
Sins Of Arcadia
10/04/2006
01:29PM
Age: 28
Location
Florida, USA
Tempus
*looks at your last.fm*

Ahaha, cute.

Well, this certainly wasn't a predictable and sub-par reply.
Sins Of Arcadia
10/04/2006
01:31PM
Age: 28
Location
Florida, USA
awake_and_avenge
Good album, dull review.

lmao, this review has more substance than most, especially considering nobody bothers with this type of music here.

*looks at your s/n*

Oh, nevermind. You're that fellow that gave the incoherent review of The Descent.

Moving on.
awake_and_avenge
10/04/2006
01:34PM
Age: 29
Location
Tucson, AZ
As always, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.
Bob Loblaw
10/04/2006
01:35PM
Boring...
Sins Of Arcadia
10/04/2006
01:38PM
Age: 28
Location
Florida, USA
awake_and_avenge
As always, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.

Yes, my posts just scream off of the page.

Are you this boring in real life?
Tempus
10/04/2006
01:42PM
Location
Canada
Sins Of Arcadia
Well, this certainly wasn't a predictable and sub-par reply.


As is your taste in music, sir!

You have no clue what I listen to, so why the hell would I try to argue such a stupid and elitist comment like that.
Sins Of Arcadia
10/04/2006
01:45PM
Age: 28
Location
Florida, USA
Tempus
As is your taste in music, sir!

You have no clue what I listen to, so why the hell would I try to argue such a stupid and elitist comment like that.

It was really a passive and sarcastic comment, much like the ones I've scattered throughout the board. You, however, tried to get a bit personal with it ;)

Be that as it may, your opinion of this album has no actual effect on myself or anyone else that may enjoy it. Thus, the lack of importance of my comment, and it's passive nature.
Tempus
10/04/2006
01:48PM
Location
Canada
Hey! I'm just doing my job.
Sins Of Arcadia
10/04/2006
01:51PM
Age: 28
Location
Florida, USA
Fine with me. The more comments this thread gets, the more interest people seem to have; and in turn, the more recognition this album gets, for better or worse.
jeff the baptist
10/04/2006
01:56PM
man, I thought I sucked at reviewing albums, but this is "amazing"....
Sins Of Arcadia
10/04/2006
01:58PM
Age: 28
Location
Florida, USA
jeff the baptist
man, I thought I sucked at reviewing albums, but this is "amazing"....

lmao, I love how easy it is to get someone to actually hold an e-grudge against you. If you think this review is bad, you haven't been paying attention, or you didn't read it at all.

As for your reviews... Well, maybe I should just use more phrases like “Ben Affleck-y”. Would that be more acceptable?
Kerwin White
10/04/2006
02:00PM
Age: 26
Location
blockbuster
you tend to overate everything not named CTTS, so i'll probably pass on this.
Bukkakeface
10/04/2006
02:01PM
Age: 29
Location
Telford, PA
I've never heard of this band before, and after reading the review, I'm heading straight over to Oink to check it out.
jeff the baptist
10/04/2006
02:01PM
e-grudge? try, "you suck dong at writing" as a reason for me posting that, instead.
jeff the baptist
10/04/2006
02:03PM
but just cuz im a nice guy, here's a tip for you from a real writer: go get a dictionary, look up hyperbole, and then stop doing it.
Inevitable
10/04/2006
02:11PM
Location
Sheffield
Bukkakeface
I've never heard of this band before, and after reading the review, I'm heading straight over to Oink to check it out.


Do it man, you won't regret it..
Sins Of Arcadia
10/04/2006
02:15PM
Age: 28
Location
Florida, USA
jeff the baptist
but just cuz im a nice guy, here's a tip for you from a real writer: go get a dictionary, look up hyperbole, and then stop doing it.

First of all, using 'cuz' will get you nowhere in life.

Secondly, who actually gets a dictionary these days, especially while typing on a computer? dictionary.com ftw.

Finally, there's a difference between hyperbole and actually describing one's feelings for an album and the contents within it by using facts and literal examples. The reviews I write show this.

Because your reviews lack substance in no way means myself or anyone else should follow suit.

Almost 25 replies already :D
Fractal_Mortality
10/04/2006
02:15PM
I'm not sure why everyone's hating on the reviewer, but I have no experience with him either way, and can safely say he did not overrate this album.

It's easily the best metal of the year, or perhaps just behind mastodon.

Sins Of Arcadia
10/04/2006
02:16PM
Age: 28
Location
Florida, USA
Bukkakeface
I've never heard of this band before, and after reading the review, I'm heading straight over to Oink to check it out.

Now this is what I'm looking to do with my reviews.

Hope you like it man.