Cursive - Mama, I'm Swollen

Rating

single starsingle starsingle star

RIYL

Murder by Death
Bear vs. Shark
Thursday

Release Date

03/10/2009

Label

Saddle Creek

Tracklist

1.) In the Now
2.) From the Hips
3.) I Couldn't Love You Anymore
4.) Donkeys
5.) Caveman
6.) We're Going to Hell
7.) Mama, I'm Satan
8.) Let Me Up
9.) Mama, I'm Swollen
10.) What Have I Done?

Users Rating

single starsingle starsingle starhalf star
10 ratings

Your Rating

Create an account or log in to rate this album

Recent Ratings

Here we are again. It seems as though when listening to Cursive, you can’t help but think of The Ugly Organ. Yes, we came upon this fact when Happy Hollow was released as they decided to change from a string section to a horn section to feed our appetite. With the release of Mamma, I’m Swollen, however, Cursive decided not to really change things up this time around. With Tim Kasher’s want to change the face of rock, it may seem as a bit of a let down that there hasn’t been a new element added to the Cursive potion. Mamma, I'm Swollen will seem mediocre at best after only one listen. After a few listens, though, it will grow on you because in the back of your head you still know what they’re capable of doing, even if they don't always do it on this album.

Still, there is no doubt that this is a Cursive album, especially when it comes to Kasher’s distinctive vocals and the band’s knack for making their own brand of heavy indie-rock sound. It also helps that there is still a horn section to compliment the distorted crunch of the guitars. Most notable, however, are the bass lines laid down by Matt Maginn. They add a much darker aura to the album which is best represented in the album’s opener “In the Now”.  Charging ahead, one of Kasher’s best lines can be found in the opening track as well where he claims, “So history repeats / because the present won’t repent.” It shows that Kasher hasn’t lost his ability to pen insightful lyrics that make us smile as we think, “You clever son-of-a-bitch.”

There are solid songs on this album, such as “From the Hips”, a song building to a momentous climax as Kasher sings about the joys and the criticism of sexual enjoyment. On the flip side, there is the obvious filler “I Couldn’t Love You”, which contains clichéd lyrics backed by boring and uninspired music. The want for Cursive to redeem themselves grows after such let downs. To make up for the lack of ingenuity, the confessional “What Have I Done?” finds Kasher asking himself where his life is going and what he’s done with it so far. The passion found in this track is palpable, with the explosive climax of the song finding Kasher screaming, “What have I done?” It might just be one of the best Cursive songs penned.

On the other side, to balance things out, there is the predictable “Caveman”, a song that is said on their website to apparently reference Pinocchio, which is barely noticeable. Still, haven’t we already heard a song about him with “Driftwood: A Fairy Tale”?

It's true, believe it or not Cursive is fallible. They created another album full of enjoyable and inventive music, but with a few songs that may see you pressing skip. It is important, though, to look at what a band has done in the past in order to see if a band has evolved or not or if they’re just using the same tired equation. For Cursive, this feels like the next step in their evolution, as there aren’t many original acts like them left, but it's definitely a small step, potentially off to the side instead of forward.

--Andrew Beam

Author

happyknappy11
Last updated: 09/29/2009 09:04PM

Comments

monkeybars
04/07/2009
03:46PM
Age: 27
Location
Markham, ON

Didn't even know this was coming out.  I'm pretty excited to hear it now.

P.S. This is what the alphabet would look like if you removed Q and R.

Zach Roth
04/08/2009
04:48AM
Age: 26
Location
Fishers, Indiana

Good review, although your RIYLs seriously misrepresent the level of energy on this disc.

Top Albums: 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 || Tumblr | Twitter

logan37
04/08/2009
09:45AM
Age: 23
Location
Toronto

I really like this album. Probably more around a 3.5 or 4 for me

Stinkypickle
04/09/2009
06:05AM

Never got this bad. What's the big deal?

Dave Spak
04/11/2009
11:56AM
Location
Boston, MA

Love this album, very underrated

AlexBurton
04/12/2009
12:39PM

This band peaked. The Burst and Bloom EP, Domestica, and Ugly Organ were all great, but everything before and after has just been kinda blah.

danielwasilewski
05/12/2011
10:51AM

This has bugged me since I first read this review 2 years ago, which is the only reason I will comment on it. Sorry for the bump.

"Caveman" is Tim Kasher wishing to go back to simpler time in his life. He wants to leave behind all the responsibilities and such of adulthood, not a Pinocchio reference. "Donkeys" has the reference to Pinocchio. He  talks about going to "fantasy island" and getting shit faced and acting like a jackass. It is another reference to the same story, but at least a different aspect of it.

End.

snoopydogg
05/12/2011
12:07PM
Age: 30
Location
California

Just wanted to add I'm a little swollen right now thinking about Pippa Middleton nude pics.  That is all.

Zach Roth
05/12/2011
02:34PM
Age: 26
Location
Fishers, Indiana

Clutch post on your part, but her forehead looks swollen, like the rest of her face is too tiny for the front of her head. Do not want.

Top Albums: 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 || Tumblr | Twitter