La Dispute - Somewhere at the Bottom of the River Between Vega and Altair

Rating

single starsingle starsingle starsingle starhalf star

RIYL

mewithoutyou
Refused
Thursday
At the Drive-In

Tracklist

01. Such Small Hands
02. Said the King to the River
03. New Storms for Older Lovers
04. Damaged Goods
05. Fall Down, Never Get Back Up Again
06. Bury Your Flame
07. Last Blues for Bloody Knuckles
08. The Castle Builders
09. Andria
10. Then Again, Maybe You Were Right
11. Sad Prayers for Guilty Bodies
12. The Last Lost Continent
13. Nobody, Not Even the Rain

Users Rating

single starsingle starsingle starsingle starhalf star
20 ratings

Your Rating

Create an account or log in to rate this album

Recent Ratings

Max
single starsingle starsingle starsingle starsingle star

Rarely does it happen any more where you come across an album by a band you’ve never heard of and it totally, utterly floors you. Labels are promoting bands from the moment they sign them, bands themselves are putting up songs on their Myspace pages and begging people to listen to them, and with the proliferation of services such as Pandora, Last.fm, and RateYourMusic people can easily find bands similar to what they already listen to. With so much at a person's fingertips, by the time you get an album in your hands, you already have heard at least a few songs, read a review or three, or (most likely) you’ve already downloaded the album and are now only buying it because you either want to support the band, it was finally released after having leaked ages ago, there's no vinyl version of the album, or you are one of the dying breed of CD lovers and collectors. There is no surprising educated music listeners any more, which is why it is all that more notable that La Dispute came out of nowhere to surprise the hell out of me with their album Somewhere at the Bottom of the River Between Vega and Altair. It’s kind of a mouthful, but is fitting considering the depth of the album.

From the outset you’ll hear three very strong influences in La Dispute’s work — mewithoutyou, At the Drive-In, and Circle Takes the Square. There’s no denying the extreme similarity between the vocal approach of Jordan Dryer and mewithoutyou’s Aaron Weiss. Dryer has a very meandering spoken yell that is used in much the same manner as Weiss. Dryer also has a propensity to write sprawling, unconventionally epic lyrics with layers of meaning (or, depending upon your interpretation, just a load of stream of consciousness mush), much in the same manner as Weiss. I will go out on a limb here, however, and say that Dryer is the superior vocalist for two reasons. First, the lyrics are truly some of the best I've come across in ages, not only because of the interesting metaphors, but also because of the storytelling nature of many songs. It’s rare to find yourself actively interested in the lyrical content of band. Second, Dryer is undeniably commanding, especially on the supremely epic 12 minute song, “The Last Lost Continent”, where he stretches himself and shows everything he has from calm storytelling to leading gang vocals to his aggressive and emotional yells.

Now La Dipute aren't all about Dryer and his vocals. The backdrop that the rest of the band creates for Dryer’s vocal and lyrical attack is nearly as amazing. With a very strongly influenced At the Drive-In post-hardcore feel and some notably Refused and Thursday shaded moments, you will be overwhelmed by the combination of heavy, brooding guitar lines and the quick paced rhythm section, often being augmented by a competing second guitar, upping the tempo or adding yet another layer to the mix. From the twinkling guitars of “Such Small Hands” to the punk intro of “New Storms for Older Lovers” to the soulful “Fall Down, Never Get Back Up Again” to the Fall of Troy inflected “Last Blues for Bloody Knuckles”, there is definitely loads of diversity and plenty of interesting ideas.

I know I’ve been sick of release after release simply conforming to genre conventions in order to appeal to a particular demographic, so it is very eye (and ear) opening to find a band that is trying to branch out and push into interesting territory. Sure, you can claim they’re just trying to appeal to the post-hardcore, counter-scene scene, but that might be pushing it since, if there is a scene for this type of music, it’s a pretty small group. Go out on a limb and enjoy something outside of what’s being pushed by the various scenes. Dive into the epic storytelling and songwriting of La Dispute!

--Rick Gebhardt

Author

Rick Gebhardt
Last updated: 09/29/2009 09:01PM

Comments

homemadebullshit
12/02/2008
02:33PM
Age: 28
Location
Ann Arbor, MI
sounds very promising i will give this a listen!!!!!

DETH ROK!!!!

Composing
12/02/2008
02:49PM
Age: 25
Location
Waterloo, Ontario
that's one hell of a RIYL. I'll check this out.
Zach Roth
12/02/2008
03:18PM
Age: 23
Location
Fishers, Indiana
Holy fucking hell everything about this review scream amazing. I have to hear this.

Top Albums: 2011 | 2010 | 2009 || Tumblr | Twitter

GodzillaVsSinatra
12/02/2008
03:28PM
Location
Atlanta
This is really pretty good.
FinchSCF
12/02/2008
03:51PM
Age: 25
Location
Holt, MI
Vocalist's voice bothers me a little at times, but overall this is an awesome surprise. Didn't know there was another album I needed to grab before the end of year.
BigM1ke
12/02/2008
04:00PM
Age: 30
Location
Drummondville, Quebec
Hmmm... At The Drive-In and Thursday?? I'm definitively interested!!
Zach Roth
12/02/2008
04:03PM
Age: 23
Location
Fishers, Indiana
I definitely hear the Thursday. They're really unique sounding. The six songs on their myspace that cover their discography are incredible as a unit. Everything sounds remarkably different.

Top Albums: 2011 | 2010 | 2009 || Tumblr | Twitter

GodzillaVsSinatra
12/02/2008
04:09PM
Location
Atlanta
^^^ Totally agree. It's almost as if mewithout you started punching the trees they hug.
BlakeW
12/02/2008
04:17PM
Location
Oklahoma
GodzillaVsSinatra
^^^ Totally agree. It's almost as if mewithout you started punching the trees they hug.


...or [A-->B] Life era mwY. The song I listened to on Myspace could have been on that album.

I dig.
pantsmeetshit
12/02/2008
06:06PM
Age: 26
Location
Los Angeles
boring
xtakesthesquare
12/02/2008
11:45PM
Location
New Jersey
I absolutely loved Vancouver, can't wait to hear this.

when i see it in your eyes
i just want to go blind

ATOMIChaelBOMB
12/03/2008
12:21AM
Age: 31
Location
Claremont, CA
this is definitely the best new music i've heard in a long while...fuckin a. some seriously deep lyrics too. excellent.
Rick Gebhardt
12/03/2008
06:10AM
Age: 30
Location
Minnesota
As ridiculously awesome as I thought this disc was, I was worried there would be nothing but haters commenting on it. It's quite a surprise to see most everyone enjoying it. My jaw dropped at hearing this album and that doesn't happen often, so I'm glad everyone else seems to feel the same way.

Find me EVERYWHERE:

Rick Gebhardt
12/03/2008
06:17AM
Age: 30
Location
Minnesota
Also, as I listen through this yet again, does Dryer sound a little bit like a pissed off version of Violent Femmes' Gordon Gano? I keep getting that vibe.

Find me EVERYWHERE:

Wolf I Am!
12/04/2008
01:17AM
This is really good, mewithoutYou and thursday vibes are overflowing from this not sure how I feel about that though...
BigM1ke
12/04/2008
04:16AM
Age: 30
Location
Drummondville, Quebec
After watching this review, I've decided to take a look at this record. It took 4.5 seconds approx. to fall in love with this band. The intro got me as fast as that! The singer's voice is so unique!
Inevitable
12/04/2008
04:59AM
Location
Sheffield
Reminds me of A Day in Black and White..Good stuff..
homemadebullshit
12/04/2008
12:40PM
Age: 28
Location
Ann Arbor, MI
listened to it and i like it, the vocals can get kind of annoying though.

DETH ROK!!!!

NiCK JAMES
12/04/2008
08:30PM
Age: 20
Location
Lakewood, OH
I can't find a download of this anywhere... help?
benny06
12/04/2008
10:31PM
Age: 23
Location
Kansas
hmmmm. this is good
Rick Gebhardt
12/05/2008
05:37AM
Age: 30
Location
Minnesota
@Nick
Here's where you can download the album: http://www.amazon.com/Somewhere-Bottom-River-Between-Altair/dp/B001HC6OAK/ref=dmusic_cd_album

Find me EVERYWHERE:

NiCK JAMES
12/05/2008
12:10PM
Age: 20
Location
Lakewood, OH
Anywhere... not so legal I can get it?
thecubist
12/07/2008
08:46PM
Location
PA
this is fantastic! thanks for reviewing this so that i can be exposed to it.I've been craving something new in the vein of [a-->b] mwY lately. I could kinda see the violent femmes reference in "said to be the king of the river"

A Spaceman.

Liam182
12/12/2008
04:15AM
Age: 22
Location
Aberdeenshire, Scotland
This is a fantastic review. I got it based on your review and it is an amazing album. Will definately be in my top ten albums of 2008. Im going to review this for my website, I'll post it here when I do. Does anyone else see the resemblance in vocals between this dude and Tim McIlrath?
Aaron Yarborough
12/22/2008
09:19AM
Age: 30
Location
Atascadero, CA
i just finally got around to checking this out after all the praise and it making our top last.fm lists and it's definately impressive, lovin' the vocals.

Decoymusic.com (CEO/Founder)
Blue Reef Design Studios (Web Development)
http://aarontroy.tumblr.com